Moreda threatens damages against reporters for ‘smear campaign’

Moreda threatens damages against reporters for ‘smear campaign’
Shelina Moreda speaks at a candidate forum at City Hall in October. (File photo by CRISSY PASCUAL/PETALUMA VOICE ©2026)

Shelina Moreda, who lost her bid for Petaluma mayor in the Tuesday, Nov. 3, election, sent an email to local media including Petaluma Voice accusing reporters of defamation, libel, slander, and a coordinated smear campaign.

In the email, Moreda demanded a retraction for numerous articles published in the weeks and months before the election, and suggested editors and reporters for Petaluma Voice and other media outlets – including The Press Democrat, the Petaluma Argus-Courier, KSRO, and KPCA – may be sued for damages.

“This was a malicious, coordinated libel and defamation smear campaign coordinated between you and others,” Moreda wrote in the email. “While this notice cements your full exposure to general, special, and exemplary damages … I demand a complete, retroactive correction and headline modification for ALL articles in this defamatory series immediately, dating back for the last 12 months.”

We reached out to Moreda with a detailed list of questions and clarifications for this story. She did not reply.

The message was sent to 19 different email addresses a few minutes before midnight on Thursday, Nov. 5, as election results showed incumbent Kevin McDonnell on his way to winning the seat. In addition to the news organizations, the notice was addressed to Petaluma city attorney Eric Danly, who wrote a letter during the campaign asking her to clear up questions about her residency qualifications.

It is unclear why certain people were included in the email. One recipient, Rick Green, the former executive editor of The Press Democrat, has not worked there since 2023.

And Moreda’s reference to KSRO may have been intended for KPCA, as Moreda included City Council member Janice Cader Thompson and Petaluma Voice board member Elece Hempel in the email. The pair regularly host a radio show on KPCA with Cindy Thomas called “Inside Petaluma,” and Moreda was a guest on the show in October. However, Cader Thompson had taken a leave from the show while campaigning for her own council post, so she wasn’t present during the interview.

Hempel, who took a leave of absence from the Petaluma Voice board during the election season to support the campaign of a City Council candidate, said she heard only positive feedback from Moreda and her supporters after the radio interview.

Hempel said Moreda’s letter felt like an attempt to turn the narrative or squash legitimate coverage.

“I was a little gobsmacked,” she said. “Maybe this is an act to clear her reputation, but really it's tarnishing it in a weird way because she is bringing all this ugliness back to life.”

Hempel said voters need reliable information on candidates and their campaigns, because social media platforms lack the fact-checking of legitimate news sources.

“As someone who cares deeply about our community, we need to have all the facts,” she said. “Unfortunately this election was flooded with misinformation – not even necessarily from all the candidates. It flooded social media in a way that people couldn’t really know what the facts were.”

Moreda’s loss in the mayoral race came five months after she placed third, and missed the runoff, in a primary for Sonoma County District 2 supervisor.

Her campaigns for both supervisor and mayor were beset with a number of controversies, including when Petaluma Voice broke the story that became Moreda’s biggest complaint: a revelation about a domestic violence temporary restraining order lodged against her in 2025, and dropped two months later following a settlement between Moreda and her ex-boyfriend.

Other controversies during the two runs included allegedly fabricating her age; a dispute over residency qualifications that the city ultimately accepted; questions about campaign finance reports; alleged violations of the municipal campaign sign ordinance; allegations of trying to push another candidate out of the race; refusing media interviews; and excluding reporters from campaign events advertised as public.

California has strong laws to protect reporters and newspapers from defamation lawsuits, particularly when reporting on public figures, said David Loy, legal director of the nonpartisan and nonprofit First Amendment Coalition. The national organization, based in San Rafael, advocates for free speech, government transparency, and a free press.

“A person that runs for public office is by definition a public figure,” Loy said. “By choosing to run for office they voluntarily put themselves under a microscope. As a public figure they have an incredibly high bar to justify suing someone for libel.”

It is possible, however, to successfully sue a newspaper for libel. Important factors include if the reporting is proven to have caused damages, if the facts are published with knowledge of them being false, or if the reporting displays a reckless disregard for the truth, Loy said.

Regardless, newspapers have an obligation to investigate and report the facts, and coverage that provides voters with information needed to decide for themselves how to vote, Loy said. The First Amendment plays a role in protecting journalists in that role, he added. 

“It is the function of the press to report the news, especially on someone running for public office,” he said. “Reporting the news serves the interest of democracy. The mere fact that someone was offended and upset does not mean she was defamed.”

With most votes counted in the mayor race, as of Monday, Nov. 16, McDonnell has 57% of the vote, Moreda 33%, and John Hanania 10%.

Petaluma Voice is printing Moreda’s letter, in full, to allow readers to read her complaints in her own words. We responded to Moreda that we take our responsibility to provide accurate, fact-base reporting on matters of public concern seriously, and we reviewed her concerns with the same seriousness.

"We conclude that our reporting is accurate and fair," we said. "Your note fails to point to any assertion of fact concerning you in the reporting that is false and defamatory, and indeed, there is none."

We declined to retract or otherwise amend our reporting.

We respond to some of her specific allegations in an editorial comment following her email.


Letter from Shelina Moreda

From: Shelina Moreda for Mayor <moredaformayor@gmail.com>

Sent: Thursday, 05 November 2026 23:55:35

To: Tobias Young <tyoung@petalumavoice.org>; Jennifer Sawhney <Jsawhney@petalumavoice.org>; Petaluma Voice <News@petalumavoice.org>; elecehempel@gmail.com <elecehempel@gmail.com>; Nate Seltenrich <nseltenrich@petalumavoice.org>; don.frances@arguscourier.com<don.frances@arguscourier.com>; donald.frances@pressdemocrat.com<donald.frances@pressdemocrat.com>; phil.barber@pressdemocrat.com<phil.barber@pressdemocrat.com>; rick.green@pressdemocrat.com<rick.green@pressdemocrat.com>; bruce.castleberry@pressdemocrat.com<bruce.castleberry@pressdemocrat.com>; isabel.beer@pressdemocrat.com<isabel.beer@pressdemocrat.com>; news@pressdemocrat.com <news@pressdemocrat.com>; legals@pressdemocrat.com <legals@pressdemocrat.com>; editor@arguscourier.com<editor@arguscourier.com>; pat.kerrigan@ksro.com <pat.kerrigan@ksro.com>; news@ksro.com<news@ksro.com>; ehempel@petalumanet.org <ehempel@petalumanet.org>; jcaderthompson@cityofpetaluma.org <jcaderthompson@cityofpetaluma.org>; news@kpca.fm<news@kpca.fm>

Cc: Shelina@shezracing.com <Shelina@shezracing.com>

Subject: SUBJECT: STATUTORY DEMAND FOR RETRACTION PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA CIVIL CODE SECTION 48a

SUBJECT: STATUTORY DEMAND FOR RETRACTION PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA CIVIL CODE SECTION 48a

TO: 

  • Tobias Young, Jennifer Sawhney, Nate Seltenrich, Crissy Pascual, Elece Hempel, Editors/Reporters/Board, The Petaluma Voice
  • Don Frances, Phil Barber, Rick Green, Isabel Beer, General Legal & Editorial Desk, Executive Editor, Reporters, & Legal Counsel, The Press Democrat
  • Jeff Woodworth, Pat Kerrigan, Elece Hempel, Janice Cader Thompson, Cindy Thomas, News Director, Reporters, & Station Management, KSRO Radio / Amaturo Sonoma Media Group

Pursuant to California Civil Code Section 48a, I, Shelina Moreda, hereby demand a full, distinct, and conspicuous retraction and correction of the false, misleading, and defamatory statements published about me across all recent articles, including at least the publications on (but not limited to) September 2, September 9, October 16, and October 23, 2026, and any others I may not currently be aware of, as well as all associated headlines, print editions, digital archives, emails, and multiple social media posts, shares, and comments.

Your publications, and others, have conspired and used misleading headlines and text that falsely implied an active restraining order, while you knew it was only a dismissed application, and you knew that you were reporting only a one sided argument – I put you on notice of this and instead of respecting that, you used it to further slander me and skew public perception against me. Your editors have also committed libel on social media defending their allegations that I have an active restraining order, even when an elected County Supervisor attempted to correct you on this libelous act. You instead, doubled down.

Myself and many others publicly called out the lie/defamation, and you have all continued to amplify the articles and social media defamation in comments sections, reiterations of articles, in emails, etc. The ongoing use of the smear, especially after receiving notice, demonstrates reckless disregard and complicity.

Prior Actual Notice of Defamation:

As you are fully aware, 

  • On September 1, 2026, informed Jennifer Sawhney in writing that it is inappropriate to mislead voters by writing an article claiming there was a restraining order when the request was never granted, and by publishing a request that never resulted in a finding - when in fact it was fully dismissed. You wrote the article anyway with a one-sided story and completely buried the fact that this was only a TRO Application that was completely dismissed by the court. You also did not publish the final dismissal agreement because that would be damning to the male who was involved, and would shed truth on your story.
  • On September 9, 2026, I informed Don Frances (editor of the Argus-Courier) in writing that it was inappropriate to mislead voters by claiming that this was a restraining order, when publishing a request that never resulted in a finding and instead was fully dismissed.
  • On October 12, 2026, I gave Tobias Young a verbal demand, publicly inside Petaluma City Hall, in the presence of multiple witnesses. I explicitly issued a verbal demand for a retraction and put you on notice that your reporting regarding a "restraining order" was entirely false, highly defamatory, and actively skews voter perception. I told you that it is reckless disregard for the truth to report something that is only one-sided and false. Rather than correcting the record, The Petaluma Voice maliciously weaponized my public legal protest to generate a hostile follow-up article on October 16, falsely framing my protection of my legal rights as a generic "refusal to cooperate."

This was a malicious, coordinated libel and defamation smear campaign coordinated between you and others.

  • Separately, in this same correspondence, you were put on notice that I am enrolled in the Secretary of State Safe at Home Program, and my address is protected, yet instead of respecting this, you proceeded to obtain my address and trespass onto my private property to disturb my peace and intimidate and harass me.

Specified Falsehoods and Misrepresentations Requiring Correction Across All Articles:

  1. Misleading Presentation of Legal Status: Your headlines and articles falsely imply the existence of an active or valid restraining order against me. No such order exists nor ever did; the underlying Temporary Restraining Order application was dismissed in its entirety by the court.
  2. Fabricated Financial and Tax Claims: Your publications falsely accused me of having active financial troubles by reporting on past tax liens that were long ago resolved, corrected, or issued in administrative error. Claiming I failed to provide evidence of their resolution when the active public record itself establishes they were cleared constitutes a reckless distortion of fact.
  3. Unverified Financial Misconduct Allegations: Your publications falsely claimed or heavily implied that I was illegally receiving funds. Publishing these severe, unverified allegations based on a city official's dissemination of unverified hearsay constitutes an active failure of journalistic due diligence and reckless disregard for the truth.
  4. Fabricated Behavioral Claims: Your publications falsely claimed or heavily implied that I made jokes about drinking and driving and/or was drinking and driving. I have never engaged in this behavior or made any such statements; this representation is entirely false and highly damaging.
  5. Fabricated Personal and Character Claims: Your associated personnel and media channels actively circulated and amplified entirely fabricated, highly offensive falsehoods regarding my private dating life and false allegations concerning public conduct. I have never engaged in any such activities; these statements constitute flagrant defamation per se.
  6. Deceptive Layout and Framing: Your publications deliberately structured these articles to hide the critical facts of court dismissals, public record corrections, and official clearances within the final sentences while highlighting unproven, one-sided allegations. This intentional layout misrepresents my record across subsequent articles, proving a subjective intent to deceive the public and creating a false and damaging sting that permanently harms my reputation.
  7. Manufactured Negative Narratives: Your coverage, specifically the article published on October 16, 2026, maliciously mischaracterized my explicit assertions of my legal rights as a generic refusal to cooperate.
  8. False Eligibility and Residency Allegations: Your publications in August 2026 defamatorily cast public doubt on my legal candidacy and residency status, despite the explicit fact that all legal municipal timeline requirements were strictly and completely satisfied.
  9. Manufactured Retaliatory Narratives: The October 16 article deliberately twisted my City Hall demand for a retraction into a campaign narrative claiming I "refused to sit for photos," punishing me for defending my character against known falsehoods.
  10. Fabricated Personal Profiles and Lack of Integrity Claims: Your publications in the spring of 2026 – specifically including reporting in April – falsely and maliciously claimed that I lacked integrity by misstating my age. This narrative completely distorted the fact that I had explicitly requested the omission of my exact age solely due to severe, verified personal privacy and security concerns, utilizing extended safety measures as established by my enrollment in the California Secretary of State Safe at Home program.
  11. Minimization of Professional and Business Credentials: Your publications, specifically including reporting in March 2026, deliberately minimized and mischaracterized my extensive history, operational involvement, and authentic credentials with my family farm to deceptively damage my professional reputation.
  12. Fabricated Meeting Removal Rumors: Your associated personnel and connected digital forums actively circulated entirely fabricated, malicious claims stating that I was forcefully removed or thrown out of a Petaluma City Council meeting by security for disorderly conduct. I have never been removed or expelled from any public municipal meeting; I have solely attended to exercise my protected First Amendment right to speak during public comment periods. This article occurred in May 2025 and has been recirculated as fact by your contributors many times since, including during this election, to make me appear disorderly. Which I am not.

Privacy and Program Violations: Separately, you are placed on notice that your agents actively bypassed protections associated with my enrollment in the Secretary of State Safe at Home program to engage in tortious trespass and harassment at my private residence.

While this notice cements your full exposure to general, special, and exemplary damages for the article published exactly 20 days ago today (October 16), I demand a complete, retroactive correction and headline modification for ALL articles in this defamatory series immediately, dating back for the last 12 months.

A formal correction must be published in substantially as conspicuous a manner as the original defamatory statements, including via social media, online, verbally, etc.

Signed,

Shelina Moreda

Including but not limited to: 

March 12, 2026 - "Field set for open race for Sonoma County's 2nd District supervisor seat" 

March 22, 2026 - "Sonoma County supervisor  candidate Shelina Moreda says safety precautions led her to give false age”

August 17, 2026 - "Shelina Moreda’s candidacy in Petaluma race for mayor thrown into doubt by residency status." 

August 18, 2026 - "Petaluma Mayoral Candidate Shelina Moreda Faces Eligibility Scrutiny." 

August 21, 2026 - "Moreda to remain on ballot after residency question." 

August 21, 2026 - "Petaluma says Shelina Moreda eligible to run for mayor after questions about city residency." 

August 21, 2026 - "Petaluma Mayoral Candidate Shelina Moreda Cleared For November Ballot." 

September 2, 2026 - "Mayoral candidate Moreda faced temporary restraining order in 2025," 

September 9, 2026 - "Petaluma mayor candidate Shelina Moreda hit with domestic violence restraining order..."

September 9, 2026 - "Restraining Order Details Emerge In Petaluma Mayoral Race." 

October 12, 2026 - Reader Letters / Public Commentary on Candidate Platforms 

October 13, 2026 - Public Commentary / Candidate Profile Series.

October 16, 2026 - "Mayoral candidate Shelina Moreda," 

October 20, 2026 - "Election 2026: Petaluma mayoral candidates differ on policy, 'transparency'"

October 23, 2026 - Candidate Analysis and Legal History Reviews.

October 28, 2026 - "Late money pours into Petaluma city races, stoking more controversy in mayoral contest."

October 30, 2026 - "City warns PAC supporting Moreda of potential violations”

October 31, 2026 - "Candidate's ties to charity targeted by late-election mailer."


Editor’s note regarding Moreda allegations and retraction request

Petaluma Voice stands by its reporting as being accurate, fair, informational, and relevant. 

Moreda is a public figure – as a professional motorcycle racer, an animal rescue and farming advocate, and a candidate for multiple public offices. 

Investigating and reporting on her campaign, as well as her legal issues, is a matter of public record and directly relevant to the mission of Petaluma Voice to provide election transparency, allowing voters to decide for themselves if candidates are fit for public office. Our reporting was largely based on public documents and court records.

We reached out to Moreda several times over the course of our reporting to hear her side of the story on issues, including the temporary restraining order.

There are a number of points in Moreda’s email that raise concern. We could respond to each one, but in the interest of brevity we will reply to two of her primary concerns.

Moreda’s objection to reporting on TRO

Moreda, in her email, said Petaluma Voice’s “articles falsely imply the existence of an active or valid restraining order against me. No such order exists nor ever did; the underlying Temporary Restraining Order application was dismissed in its entirety by the court.”

An application for a domestic violence temporary restraining order was granted Oct. 21, 2025. The order required Moreda to turn in firearms and ammunition; stay at least 100 yards away from her ex-boyfriend and his home, workplace, and vehicle; avoid contact with him; post nothing negative about him online; and avoid behavior that might be interpreted as harassment, threats, stalking, or disturbing the peace.

The judge dropped the temporary order – and a request for a five-year restraining order – in a Dec. 19, 2025, hearing after both sides reached a settlement. Our reporting never referenced an active restraining order, and in every case noted the temporary order was removed following the settlement.

Moreda’s claim that Petaluma Voice withheld information about the dismissal agreement is inaccurate. The agreement has not been disclosed to Petaluma Voice and was not included in court records.

Petaluma Voice was fair in its coverage, explaining that “A temporary restraining order is not a finding of guilt or liability. Instead, it is typically issued on an emergency basis by a judge, before a full hearing takes place, based on the allegations of a petitioner without the evidentiary level required of other legal orders.”

Petaluma Voice detailed the court hearings, as well as evidence supporting the ex’s request for a restraining order, which are a matter of public record. The court documents included strings of texts, images from video surveillance allegedly showing her breaking a window at a South Lake Tahoe residence where her ex claimed he had gone to escape her, and a check she allegedly left at the house to pay for the damage.

Moreda denies statements

Moreda wrote that allegations that she joked about drinking and driving were “entirely false and highly damaging.” She said she has “never engaged in this behavior or made any such statements.”

Until now, Moreda never denied making the statements in a series of text strings that were included as evidence in the court case. She did not reply for this story when asked for further explanation.

Petaluma Voice is not addressing the rest of the allegations in this story. Either they were not meant for us or we also considered them without merit.

For reference, we are including a list of our original stories regarding Moreda, as well as a story on a political action committee that supported her.

  • An Oct. 30 story quoting a city attorney who is raising questions about potential violations by a political action committee supporting Moreda.
  • An Oct. 28 story about political action committees spending money on the Petaluma mayoral race.
  • An Oct. 23 story on the contentious mayoral election and an investigation into the differences between the temporary restraining orders against two candidates.
  • An Oct. 21 story on campaign sign complaints.
  • An Oct. 16 story explaining why Moreda was not included in our profiles of the mayoral candidates.
  • A Sept. 2 story on the restraining order, and a string of texts and other evidence submitted to the court.
  • An Aug. 21 story on Moreda remaining on the ballot following questions about her residency.

Tobias Young is an editor and reporter at Petaluma Voice. He can be reached at tyoung@petalumavoice.org.

Do you like our work? Support us with a tip.

Give us a tip