Proposal near Adobe Creek draws neighborhood concerns

Proposal near Adobe Creek draws neighborhood concerns
Although the Adobe Creek Golf Club was closed in 2017, there are still signs of its existence on the property in east Petaluma. (Monday, Nov. 16, 2026 Photo by CRISSY PASCUAL/PETALUMA VOICE ©2026)

Update 10:41 a.m. 11/18/26:

Supes will reconsider Adobe Creek land change at a future, uncertain date

A change to land previously intended to be kept as open space just outside Petaluma will be reconsidered alongside a possible project at a future, unnamed date.

The Sonoma County Board of Supervisors did not vote Tuesday afternoon on a resolution that could expand the allowable uses for land next to the Adobe Creek subdivision and potentially lead to the property being annexed into Petaluma. That area includes a now defunct public golf course, which currently has an easement deeming it open space in perpetuity. 

Instead, Permit Sonoma staff recommended that the item be continued at a future date, based on “new information gathered,” said one staffer at the start of the hearing.

At the item’s conclusion, after the board and the public gave their input, Permit Sonoma’s Director Scott Orr said staff would work with the applicant because there “is a hint of a project” in the permit application that should be looked at in totality. The item would be picked back up later so staff could determine the “appropriate permitting pathway” with the public’s interest in mind.  

Despite there being no vote on the item, the board agreed to hold the original presentation, after Orr noted there was misinformation in the submitted comments. At a few points during the meeting, supervisors David Rabbit and James Gore both used the term “shit show” to describe the pending land-use changes, with Rabbit apologizing for his language at the meeting’s conclusion.


Original story published at 4:04 p.m. on 11/16/26

 Here's what you need to know:

  • A proposed permit change may lead to a polo field or a sporting facility at the now-defunct Adobe Creek Golf Club, located just outside city limits.
  • Some residents are concerned this change could lead to further development or annexation into the city of Petaluma. The property lies within Petaluma's voter-approved urban growth boundary.
  • The property owner, Richard Coombs of Adobe Investments, LLC, has stated that the permitted golf course, which closed in 2017, no longer aligns with community needs and has no long-term economic or environmental sustainability.
  • Coombs seeks to expand what could be allowed at the property: commercial horse facilities and/or sports and entertainment assembly that includes amphitheaters, race tracks, rodeo arenas, or stadiums for large-scale, spectator-oriented entertainment.
  • The item will be heard by the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors at 1:30 p.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 575 Administration Dr. 102A, Santa Rosa.

Residents at the southeast edge of Petaluma are worried that a permit application may lead to the construction of a polo field and other development on land currently intended for open space within the city's urban growth boundary, as well as an annexation of 36 acres into city limits.

The land in question is at 1901 Frates Road, the former public golf course backing up against the Adobe Creek subdivision at the edge of Petaluma. It is currently under the county’s jurisdiction, and outside Petaluma city limits, but within the city's "sphere of influence" – so it is subject to the General Plan.

Along the property on Frates Road, a fence that surrounded the former golf course is now falling apart. (Monday, Nov. 16, 2026. Photo by CRISSY PASCUAL/PETALUMA VOICE ©2026)

David Donnenfield, a resident of the subdivision, learned about the permit application in late October, and began working with neighbors to push back against the proposal.

Donnenfield said the change warrants further environmental scrutiny for several reasons: “interfering with flight operations of our airport, to disturbing the very topography of the landscape, which is rolling hills. What does the polo field need? Flat-as-a-pancake ground. What about all the horse waste? What's going to happen to that?”

He added, “There are segments of Adobe Creek which runs through the property,” that drain into the Petaluma River, and where Casa Grande High School hatchery students release steelhead trout.

Casa Grande High School teacher Dan Hubacker and his student, senior Colton Manion, check Adobe Creek for newly hatched steelhead trout. (File photo by CRISSY PASCUAL/PETALUMA VOICE ©2026)

“There's just any number of potential environmental threats,” Donnenfield said.

Several residents who purchased homes there did so knowing the nearby land was legally required to be open space in perpetuity, and it was permitted to operate as Adobe Creek Golf Club through 2039. The golf course closed in 2017, with its owner, Richard Coombs of Adobe Investments, LLC, citing major losses year over year. He previously said there is not a market for two golf courses in Petaluma (he also operates the other public course).

Signs for the former golf course remain on the property at Adobe Creek. (Monday, Nov. 16, 2026. Photo by CRISSY PASCUAL/PETALUMA VOICE ©2026)

Currently, the former golf course is a “wasteland” that no longer aligns with community needs and has no long-term economic or environmental sustainability, Coombs wrote in an application letter.

He indicated that, pending the board’s approval, it could be redeveloped as polo fields.

Donnenfield and at least one other resident said they only learned about the permit hearing via a notice mailed by the county in late October, prompting several neighbors to spread the word ahead of a scheduled Nov. 3 hearing. Residents requested a two-month delay to review documents, and the county agreed to push it back two weeks to Tuesday, Nov. 17.

Coombs submitted the application in March for a permit that would also allow commercial horse facilities and/or sports and entertainment assembly that includes amphitheaters, race tracks, rodeo arenas, or stadiums for large-scale, spectator-oriented entertainment.

An old sign from the former golf course looks like a tombstone. (Monday, Nov. 16, 2026. Photo by CRISSY PASCUAL/PETALUMA VOICE ©2026)

This proposal is “substantially similar to a golf course,” because it allows for recreational activities on a grassy field and is “entirely consistent” with what’s permitted under the existing open space easement, he argued.

A request for comment to Coombs was not immediately returned.

Other proposed changes include dividing the property into four legal parcels. Currently, the property is prohibited from being subdivided into “two or more parcels under separate ownership,” according to the existing easement.

“Future lots of a subdivision would continue to be subject to the Open Space Easement,” the Nov. 17 board packet states.

The permit change would still restrict how much can be built on the property, does not formally approve annexation or development, and does not terminate the open space easement, according to the board agenda. Further changes would be subject to additional scrutiny, including approval by the Petaluma City Council if it were to be annexed, according to the board documents.

The item will be up for a vote at 1:30 p.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 17, at the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors meeting at 575 Administration Dr. 102A, Santa Rosa. (To watch the meeting, click this link, then tap "In Progress" next to the meeting name after it has begun)

Dozens of residents of the quiet Adobe Creek subdivision have cosigned a letter protesting the proposed change. It was signed primarily by residents Phil Prince and Donnenfield.

“It appears to us that this project is a complex maneuver by Mr. Coombs and his associates to escape the land use restrictions placed on the property by the easements,” the letter reads. "Is it to create a horse-centric recreational facility, or is it a way to sneak through amendments and provisions that would support conversion of the property eventually into a new residential and mixed-use development?”

The land up for annexation currently lies within the bounds of the urban growth boundary map, which was initially adopted by voters in 1998. In 2024, 70% of Petaluma voters approved renewing the boundary, with minor policy adjustments, until 2050. The property is currently zoned as open space.

Reached by phone Sunday, Prince said there are multiple components to the proposed change that “appear to be totally unrelated. Why, if you’re going to have polo fields, why do you need to have annexation by Petaluma? It doesn’t make any sense. It’s like a puzzle that the pieces don’t fit together.”

To read more about the proposal, see the agenda item here.

The gateway entrance to Adobe Creek off Frates Road. (Monday, Nov. 16, 2026. Photo by CRISSY PASCUAL/PETALUMA VOICE ©2026)
A fence that once surrounded the Adobe Creek Golf Course is now rotted and broken. (Monday, Nov. 16, 2026. Photo by CRISSY PASCUAL/PETALUMA VOICE ©2026)

Correction 6:47 p.m. 11/16/26: Richard Coombs operates a public golf course in Petaluma.

Jennifer Sawhney is a reporter and co-founder of Petaluma Voice. She can be reached at jsawhney@petalumavoice.org.

Do you like our work? Support us with a tip.

Give us a tip